The Bandeja Lab

Home › Puzzle › The server keeps landing the serve in the same spot. Do you move?

The server keeps landing the serve in the same spot. Do you move?

Adjust your return position to the server's pattern. Wide serves: start wider. Then re-adjust when they change.

YouPartnerOpponentsBall
intermediatereturnpositioning

The server has landed five serves in a row deep and wide, into the glass. What should your starting position do?

Adjust your return position to the server's pattern. Wide serves: start wider. Then re-adjust when they change.

Why

The return position is not fixed. A server who lands the same wide serve repeatedly is telling you where to stand: a step wider and a touch deeper puts you beside the ball as it comes off the glass rather than chasing it. The server will notice and switch to the body serve: at which point you move back toward the middle and the conversation continues. Returners who never move are easy to serve to; returners who adjust make the server think, and a thinking server serves worse than one on autopilot.

What this means at your level

Beginner

If the serve keeps going to the same place, stand nearer to that place. It is allowed.

Intermediate

Adjust after two identical serves, not five. The earlier you move, the sooner they have to change.

Advanced

Move late, as they bounce the ball, so they cannot serve to your new position. Your starting spot is a decoy; your actual position is set at the last moment.


Common questions

The server has landed five serves in a row deep and wide, into the glass. What should your starting position do?

Start wider and a touch deeper. Adjust your return position to the server's pattern. Wide serves: start wider. Then re-adjust when they change. The return position is not fixed. A server who lands the same wide serve repeatedly is telling you where to stand: a step wider and a touch deeper puts you beside the ball as it comes off the glass rather than chasing it. The server will notice and switch to the body serve: at which point you move back toward the middle and the conversation continues. Returners who never move are easy to serve to; returners who adjust make the server think, and a thinking server serves worse than one on autopilot.

Why not stay put: moving shows them it is working?

Standing still while a server hits the same winning serve is the weakness. Adjust.

What should a beginner do here?

If the serve keeps going to the same place, stand nearer to that place. It is allowed.

How does this change for an advanced player?

Move late, as they bounce the ball, so they cannot serve to your new position. Your starting spot is a decoy; your actual position is set at the last moment.

Puzzles like this one